Extra time off is not a raise.
Sidebar Live, Episode 13. November 12, 2026. 24 min. Hosted by Rob, Amanda.
The question: What is still working for employee engagement: is the holiday party worth it, and can extra time off stand in for a raise?
Rob Joyner and Amanda Koplos, one week out from Thanksgiving and heading into the year-end rush of collections, bonuses, and budgets. Amanda explains how her accounting team will use Claude for the one-off reports partners ask for every December, how her firm budgeted for an enterprise plan by capping tokens per person, and why some vendor connectors are still priced out of reach for mid-sized firms. Then a member’s question that had nothing to do with AI: what keeps people engaged? 86% of responding firms are keeping the holiday party, half said plainly that extra time off is not a raise, and 61% get the most from small recognition throughout the year. Rob and Amanda trade what works at an in-office firm and a fully remote company, and close on an investor-backed law firm and whether the mid-market is splitting into boutiques.
Year-end, with Claude this time
Last year Amanda’s accounting controller had no generative AI tools. This year she has Claude, for the custom reports nobody’s software produces: only clients whose last name ends in S, opened this year, in a spreadsheet. Partners ask for a report once a year, on December 20th, to use one number. Partnership reports are next, and by next year the whole accounting and billing teams will be using more AI.
Budgeting an enterprise plan
Amanda’s firm budgeted for Claude by the token limit it set for each person, so the budget is the maximum spend and raising anyone’s limit has a known cost. Training should bring the real number in lower by teaching people to pick the right model. Rollout is two-pronged, like a document management implementation: a big launch, then coffee chats, open office hours, and someone on site all year asking what problem they can help solve.
Connectors and pricing
Amanda’s firm is connecting the systems that will connect, but some vendors are holding data behind premium tiers that mid-sized firms cannot afford. In her words, the MCPs exist, they are just not correctly priced for the market.
Is the holiday party still worth it?
Last week’s question came straight from a member, with salary compression and rising health insurance costs as the backdrop. 86% of responding firms are keeping the holiday party in some form. Many are adapting it: moving it to January, when venues are easier to book and cheaper, or making it employee only. Rob’s fully remote company replaced its party, and he found the budget means more spread across the year.
Extra time off is not a raise
Asked whether they give extra time off in lieu of pay increases, half of responding firms said very plainly that extra time off is not a raise, and their people know it. 61% said they have the most success with small recognition throughout the year, with the holiday party as the cap on a year of recognition, not the only touch.
The small things
Handwritten notes, anniversary gifts, and a “my favorite things” questionnaire for new hires, so a thank-you is flowers and not an umbrella. Beverage carts, surprise pizza, weekly trivia, and a themed snack cart that tracks what people actually take. Amanda’s firm runs Thankful Thursdays every week in November. Her NFL pick’em write-up, drafted with a custom GPT trained on her jokes, is a weekly hit.
Recognition when you are remote
Rob’s company gives swag shop credits (mind the de minimis fringe benefit rules), runs desk-friendly virtual activities like woodblock carving, brings teams together a couple of times a year, and votes quarterly MVPs that must tie back to a core value. Shout-outs are read aloud at the weekly stand-up. Being recognized in front of your team is motivating and cost-effective. Amanda adds a favorite from her last firm: after a trial win, a firm-wide email credited everyone who helped, from the partner to the records clerk.
Will the mid-market split into boutiques?
Rob had dinner with a partner at an investor-backed firm, where partners trade some annual cash for equity and lean on the sponsor’s technology and operations know-how. His view: the mid-market will see more mid-sized boutiques that specialize. Amanda disagrees. A small business owner with a few pizza shops needs corporate, employment, estate, and real estate work, and would rather have one firm that knows them than four. Rob counters that focus lets a firm perfect its workflows and price on value.
Transcript
Five Fridays till Christmas
Rob: And we’re live. Sidebar Live, here for another week.
Rob: Amanda, I like to do this every week, but we’re one full week out from Thanksgiving. Next week is your last week.
Amanda: Oh my gosh.
Rob: Until December starts. The December rush.
Amanda: Collections.
Rob: Collections and bonuses.
Amanda: Listen, what law firms do is we spend 11 months making the money and one month trying to figure out how to divvy it up. It’s our business.
Rob: What a bad problem.
Amanda: Especially. I know it’s our busiest time of year in admin, for a variety of reasons: reviews and budgeting. It just is. Somebody told me...
Rob: Hold on. Amanda, if you’re going to listen to the presentation, put it on silent on your phone.
Amanda: Okay, stop. I didn’t realize it was still on. So yeah, somebody told me yesterday, there are only five Fridays till Christmas. And I’m like, get out of my office. Get out. I can’t even talk about Fridays till Christmas.
Amanda: But you already have your Christmas trees, plural, up. So you guys are set.
Rob: The house is lit, the trees are up. The only thing I’m waiting for is the presents to hit the credit card.
Amanda: And the surprise about what all your kids got, because the shopping’s done and you don’t even know.
Rob: Yeah, exactly. Although we did just get them a 3D printer for their birthday.
Amanda: I saw that. That’s pretty exciting.
Rob: Yes. And let’s just say I’m enjoying it too.
Amanda: The second I saw that, I thought, that’s half for Rob. Or at least 33%, since the twins have to share.
Rob: Nobody cares about me, though. So let’s talk about...
Amanda: Not about me either. Let’s talk about law firms.
Year-end reports with Claude
Rob: Actually, I know where we want to dive in, last week’s question. But one question for you first. You’re going into this season of distributing money and collecting it. Are you doing it any differently this year with the tools you have?
Amanda: Yeah. What’s interesting is that last year, our accounting controller didn’t have access to any generative AI programs. This year she’s going to be using Claude, and I’m really hopeful it will speed up a lot of the “can you create this custom report that does this, this, and this.” Because we can get the data, but then they want: only show me clients whose last name ends in S and who were opened this year, and I want that in a spreadsheet. No software you use is necessarily going to replicate that directly. So I’m excited, because I think it’s going to be really helpful for her. That’s one thing we’ll be doing differently with AI: just using the tools to get data faster. The requests come at us constantly. Just when you think you’ve provided all the financial data they’re going to need, it’s the nuance. You’ve been in this. We need a report that shows this, this, and this. And how many times a year do you use that report?
Rob: Once, on December 20th, every year.
Amanda: And what do you use from that report?
Rob: One thing. One number.
Amanda: Did you need the whole report?
Rob: No, I just needed the number. I just need that number.
Amanda: Yeah, exactly. And we’ve also talked about preparing the partnership reports, how many pages that is and how long it takes, and how we’ll be able to use AI to speed some of that up. So hopefully we’ll see some change. This is really just our first year of opening it up. But by next year, the whole accounting team and the whole billing team will be using more AI products.
Budgeting for Claude by token limit
Rob: If you don’t mind me asking, how are you budgeting for Claude next year, now that you and many firms are on an enterprise plan?
Amanda: We budgeted based on the token limits we’re putting on everybody individually. That way we’re at least at the high end of what the spend is going to cost us. If we have to raise anybody’s token limit, we know it has a direct impact on budget. Ideally we come in under that, because training will hopefully teach people to use the right models so we don’t overspend on tokens, and yada yada yada. But our budget is just the max we gave everybody for tokens.
Rob: How did you figure out that budget? Did you let people play with it for a month?
Amanda: We’re using really great consultants to tell us.
Training that sticks
Rob: Oh, there you go. No, that’s good. I’m thinking of the questions other people might ask. To make sure it sticks next year, are you also doing continuous training?
Amanda: Yes. Yep. Our implementation is a two-pronged approach. We’ve got people on the ground who will be here throughout the year, and then people coming in to do a big implementation. I think about it a lot like when we implemented our document management software. It impacts every single person who touches a computer. So we have a rollout and implementation, and then we’ll do coffee chats, meetings, open office hours. We’ll have somebody on site going from person to person throughout the year: what are your problems, how can I help you solve them? And just expanding our skills and connectors, etc., etc.
Rob: I’m sure there’s going to be some show-and-tell element to that. But when you say it’s like implementing a document management system: there you’re doing a big data conversion, and then teaching people how the user experience works. You’re obviously going to train on the user experience. Are you also going to connect all your different software? I know you mentioned connecting different things.
Connectors priced out of reach
Amanda: The stuff that will connect, yes. But what we’re finding... and I know you’re making a face, but you won’t be able to make that face in ’27.
Rob: I wasn’t making that face about Centerbase. I was making that face about...
Amanda: Others. Others. And it’s not that the MCPs aren’t there. They’re just still not correctly priced for the market, is what I say. You’ll disagree with that, I know. But we feel like some of our data might be being held hostage, or they’re only offering it to premium customers, and mid-sized firms can’t afford the premium prices some of these companies are choosing to charge.
Last week’s question: is the holiday party still worth it?
Rob: I understand. I deal with the same thing when we connect to different MCPs. Okay. Well, today, Amanda, we’re going to go over last week’s question.
Amanda: Which was a non-AI question.
Rob: It was great. It makes me happy when we get emails saying, can you help me with this? Can you ask this to the group? So you can always submit questions. Do you want to go into what it was?
Amanda: Sure. So last week, and as Rob mentioned, the question came straight from one of our users. What she really wanted to understand is what’s sticking with employee engagement. We hear this question a lot. I’ve been hearing it every year in the 23 or so years I’ve worked in law firms: is the holiday party still worth it? What motivates people? Is it PTO? Salary? Because salary compression is very real right now, across the country. I’ve talked about health insurance prices going up. So what do you still use to motivate employees, and what’s working? We came up with five takeaways, but the biggest one is that 86% of responding firms are keeping the holiday party, because people still like it. I know you hate the holiday party because it requires you to be around people, but not everybody does.
Rob: No, I used to enjoy the holiday party. We’re different because we’re not local.
Amanda: Yeah, you’re remote.
Rob: And so we’ve modified it. I was kind of disappointed the first year it went away. But it’s also kind of relieving, honestly, because you have so many other holiday parties.
Extra time off is not a raise
Amanda: Right. So 86% are keeping the holiday party, and many of them are trying to adapt it. At my last firm, we had our holiday party in January every year, for a couple of reasons. Schedules were easier, and the hotel or restaurant where you’re having the party is usually easier and cheaper to book in January. They’re seeing more and more firms do that. Some are making it employee-only, some are expanding it. Honestly, it hasn’t changed much, because a lot of people have been doing it that way for decades. But 86% said they’re still keeping it in some form, whatever works best for their firm. Then the other part of the question was: are you giving extra time off in lieu of pay increases? And half of our respondents said, very plainly, extra time off is not a raise, and your people know it.
Amanda: That was interesting. 61% of our respondents said they have the most success with small recognition throughout the year, and that the holiday party is the cap on a year of recognition, not the only touch they have.
Small recognition all year
Rob: Yeah, I like the little things throughout the year too. We do, and I take no credit for any of this when I say we: Centerbase does quarterly voting for MVP. You nominate, and then there are MVPs every quarter. It keeps people aligned, keeps people motivated, keeps people excited. And I agree with you. It makes a difference.
Amanda: Honestly, none of this is revolutionary. It’s just that sometimes we all need to hear it. Some of the specific things mentioned: the handwritten note, the anniversary gift. I love this one: having new people fill out a “my favorite things” questionnaire, so you know what people really like. When you want to recognize someone, you’re not giving them an umbrella if they really like flowers. Like sending yellow Starbursts, or something like that.
Rob: Or Dots.
Amanda: Or Dots.
Rob: If there are any salespeople listening who want to get to Amanda: yellow Starbursts and Dots.
Amanda: Well, listen, Halloween just happened. We have an entire bowl full of Starbursts in every color, because I open every single one our kids get and pull out all the yellows. It’s the only good flavor. Everything else gets tossed.
Rob: There you go.
Snack carts and Thankful Thursdays
Amanda: Some other small options came up this week: beverage cart runs, surprise pizza, weekly trivia, a snack cart. We do a summer snack cart. Actually, we do a fairly frequent snack cart, and she themes it. Today it was a fall-themed snack cart. We had an international foods one at one point. She did a Harry Potter-themed snack cart. I don’t do Harry Potter and didn’t understand any of it. I was like, can you just give me the jerky? She does it during the summer, and then periodically throughout the year. And around Thanksgiving we do Thankful Thursdays: something every single Thursday for employees. And one of the Thursdays is the firm-wide Thanksgiving.
Rob: I like a snack.
Amanda: I know. I bet you do. And when she sees what people are taking and what people love, she makes sure those are on there the next time. She also makes note of, you know, Jim Bob loves the jerky, so keep it in stock. It is little things, but...
Rob: I feel like when we stopped doing the holiday party, everybody griped and had comments the first year. But when you see that budget dispersed throughout the year, it’s more meaningful.
Amanda: Yeah, it’s more meaningful at different moments.
Rob: Right, right.
Recognition when you are fully remote
Amanda: I think that’s true. You guys are fully remote, and I talked about a lot of ideas we use. What are some of the things you all do, fully remote, for employee recognition?
Rob: We have a swag shop with different company swag, so a lot of the smaller things come as credits for the swag shop. You’d know this better than I do, but some of that is based on taxes, how it’s taxed when you give it out.
Amanda: De minimis fringe benefits.
Rob: Sounds good. Another thing we do during the holidays is some kind of activity. They’ve done woodblock carving and other unique things you can do from a desk, and we’ve done some of those activities virtually, which is fun. You can pull your kids in. It’s nice, it’s easy, and it doesn’t require you to go out and dress up some night. And even though we’re virtual, we try to get our teams together a couple of times a year, whether that’s the entire team or different departments, just to do fun activities.
Amanda: You talked about it briefly, but you do a much better employee-of-the-month type thing. You do innovator of the month. And Debbie does that too: innovator of the month and most valuable player. They really focus on the results certain people deliver, which makes it easier than plain employee of the month, because different people contribute in different ways.
Rob: We tie it back to our core values. If you’re going to recommend somebody for MVP, it has to tie into one of the core values.
Amanda: I like that.
Rob: And we have an employee of the month, I think, and a stand-up once a week where we cover those things. We also have a system for shout-outs, and that’s all intertwined. We read out those shout-outs, we give the MVP awards. It’s meaningful to get recognized in front of your team. And honestly, it’s motivating and cost-effective to do it that way.
Amanda: Yeah, I like it.
Rob: What else? What are firms doing? I’d love to hear from people.
NFL pick’em, written with AI
Amanda: Oh, can I? One more I’ve got.
Rob: Yeah, go ahead. You’ve got a lot more.
Amanda: One more we have is football pick’em. Not fantasy football, NFL pick’em. That one’s really easy, because there are between 10 and 16 games each week and you just pick the winner. Then at the end of the week I do a big write-up with a bunch of funny stories and my own personal bias. Am I writing the whole thing myself? Absolutely not. I use ChatGPT for this, because I don’t want my fun side stuff messing with my Claude. I have a whole custom GPT, I guess they call it, and if I make changes to the language, I update it, so it’s learning my side jokes and my preference for the Packers. People say, wow, I’m really impressed you know so much about football. And I’m like, yes, I know so much about football. But I take every chance to dig at the Dallas Cowboys and the Chiefs, every single week.
Credit for everyone who helped win
Rob: Those are two easy teams to dig at, being a Cowboys fan. Amanda, I was thinking about when you and I spent so much time on the road doing Legal on the Road. We talked about recognition and what employees were looking for. My brain doesn’t time-travel very well, but are there any you can think of that people brought up?
Amanda: Like, for people in an in-person office, giving a certificate for a remote work day.
Rob: Yeah, that was interesting.
Amanda: Gosh, why can’t I think? It’s all about personal recognition. Just telling people they did a good job. It’s crazy how hard we think about what this should look like and what that should look like. But I always say: if you’re a litigation firm and you win a trial... my last firm was really good at this. They would send out a write-up of the trial. We were a huge firm, but every single person who helped, from the partner down to the file clerk, down to the records clerk who was profiling emails, got credit for working on that trial in a firm-wide email. I always thought that was really valuable.
An investor-backed law firm
Rob: So what else did we learn on Sidebar? I’m going to go totally off topic, Amanda, and I think you’ll find this interesting. This Saturday night we had a couple over, and the husband is a partner at a law firm that is very different from most. Instead of the traditional model, they’re backed by an investor. One of the big differences in a firm like that is you have to get people bought into the idea of making less cash each year and getting more of what a traditional executive gets: equity, like you see at a lot of companies. That was one interesting thing. Two others came up. One is that a reason you take an investment like this is to leverage your sponsor’s understanding of technology and operations, where a law firm usually struggles. So they’re really building themselves for the future, to serve the mid-market, using a lot of technology, some names you know and some you don’t. The other piece was where the mid-market is going. His perspective was: you have a lot happening up-market and a lot happening down-market, and in the mid-market he thinks you’re going to get more mid-sized boutiques that specialize in certain practices. What do you think about this?
Will the mid-market split into boutiques?
Amanda: Yes. I think it’s hard, because one of the things that makes midsize firms unique is their ability to serve mid-sized clients in all their legal needs. A boutique model means some small business owners may need multiple law firms. Let’s say you own three or four local pizza shops. You need corporate attorneys to do a franchise agreement, you need an employment lawyer for employment law, you want to make sure your estate plan is done, and you want to lease real estate. For some of these small companies, it’s just like buying all-in-one software. They like having an all-in-one firm that can handle all their legal needs. So I think there’s still a place for that, especially for clients like that. As a consumer, do you want four law firms? Because then they all have to know you differently. So I tend to disagree with that, but obviously I could be wrong. I thought it was a really interesting take.
Rob: Yeah. One of the benefits is perfecting the workflows within the firm, not having to cater to every different practice area, and being able to offer services at a more effective, value-based price.
Amanda: Right, right. Yeah, I can see that.
Join Sidebar, and this week’s question
Rob: Which, you know, we’ll see where it goes. But it’s all interesting. If you take one thing away, it’s to go join Sidebar. Go to gosidebar.ai. If you want to email us, you can find that on the website. Our community is still growing. We have about 130 firms represented now in the mid-market, so a good piece of the pie to get continuous feedback. You can submit questions to us. We’re here to help. So reach out to us and join the community. And Amanda, what do you want to say?
Amanda: This week our question goes in a completely different direction, a much more serious question: are there concerns that have come up for you individually, or at your firm, about the impact AI data centers are having? And have recent political actions made you think or rethink AI data centers, and whether that might change what you’re thinking about your own AI usage? It’s a pretty deep topic, but timely. We’re trying to be very timely.
Rob: And if you join, you not only get the feedback there, you get a summary of what’s going on in the market for midsize law firms every week, on Saturday morning. A lot of great value, totally free. So make sure you sign up. We appreciate you joining us. See you next week. Hopefully we might have a third person too, but not on Thanksgiving, for sure.
Amanda: No, no, no. Of course not.
Rob: We’ll catch you later. Thanks for joining us. See you soon.